Lock Rekeying Service in Sarasota — Same-Day Rekey

What Is Lock Rekeying?

Lock rekeying is the process of altering the internal pins of your existing lock so that old keys no longer work and a completely new set of keys opens the lock instead. The lock body, hardware, and mounting stay exactly the same — only the internal mechanism changes. This is one of the fastest and most cost-effective ways to gain control over access to your property.

Whether you've just purchased a home and don't know who has copies of the old keys, you've lost your house keys, or you're managing a rental property where a tenant is moving out, rekeying is the smart choice. It's faster than full lock replacement and keeps your existing hardware intact.

How Lock Rekeying Works

Rekeying involves removing and rearranging the internal pins (the small metal cylinders that make up the lock's mechanism) so that a different key cuts match them.

Lock Disassembly — Our technician removes the plug (the rotating part) from the lock body using a specialized tool.
Pin Removal — The old pins are taken out of the plug and set aside.
New Pin Installation — New pins are carefully selected, measured, and inserted into the plug in the correct order to match your new key blank.
Reassembly — The plug is reinserted into the lock body, and the lock is reassembled to factory specification.
Testing — Your new key is tested in the lock to ensure smooth operation. Any old keys will no longer work.

The entire process is non-destructive — your lock hardware remains completely intact and fully functional, just with a new key. This is why rekeying is ideal for rental properties, newly purchased homes, or any situation where you need to change who has access.

When Should You Rekey Your Locks?

Consider rekeying in any of these situations:

After Buying a Home — You don't know who has copies of the previous owner's keys. Rekeying ensures only your keys open the doors.
Lost or Stolen Keys — If you can't account for all copies of your key, rekeying guarantees the lost or stolen key no longer works.
Tenant Turnover — Property managers and landlords rekey between tenants to maintain security and control over building access.
After a Break-In — You may want new keys even if the lock wasn't damaged, especially if keys were lost during the intrusion.
Unauthorized Copies — If you suspect someone has made unauthorized copies of your key, rekeying immediately revokes all old keys.
Moving Into a Rental — Some rental properties benefit from rekeying if you're concerned about previous occupant access.
Employee Separation — Businesses rekey after employee departures to remove access for former staff.

Rekeying vs. Lock Replacement — Which One Do You Need?

Rekeying is the right choice when:

Your existing locks are in good working condition
The hardware matches your doors and décor
You simply need new keys to control access
You want to save money on lock hardware

Lock replacement is better when:

Your lock is damaged or broken
The lock is old, worn, or unreliable
You want to upgrade to a higher-security lock or smart lock
The existing lock won't accept new pins (rare, but possible with very old locks)
You want to match new hardware across multiple doors or rooms

Not sure which option is right for your situation? Call us at +1 (941) 297-5289. Our technicians will assess your locks on-site and recommend the most cost-effective solution. If you need full lock replacement, we also offer professional lock replacement service.

What Affects Your Rekeying Quote

Several factors influence the cost of rekeying your locks:

Number of Locks — More locks mean more work. Most rekeying jobs involve the front door, back door, and garage entry — but you may have additional doors you want rekeyed.
Lock Type — Standard pin-and-tumbler deadbolts are fastest to rekey. High-security locks, keypad locks, or specialty hardware may require more time.
Lock Condition — Locks that are rusty, stuck, or difficult to open take longer to service. Extensive buildup inside the lock requires careful cleaning before rekeying.
Keyed-Alike Option — You can have all your locks rekeyed to the same key (very convenient for homeowners) or to different keys (common in commercial settings). Some locks may not support the same key cut.
Key Quantity — We'll provide a standard number of new keys per lock, but additional key copies are available.
Accessibility — If a lock is difficult to reach or requires special positioning, it may take longer.

Our technician will perform a complete on-site assessment and provide a transparent quote before any work begins. No surprises, no hidden fees.

Our Rekeying Service Promise

90-Day Labor Warranty — If any issue arises with our rekeying work within 90 days, we return to fix it at no cost.

Non-Destructive First — We use specialized tools to disassemble locks without damage. Your hardware stays intact.

Transparent Pricing — You get a clear, itemized quote before work begins. The price quoted is the price you pay.

Fully Insured — We carry comprehensive liability insurance for peace of mind on every job.

Mobile Service — We come to you with all tools and equipment. No need to remove locks or visit a shop.

Service Areas

We provide lock rekeying throughout the Sarasota and Bradenton area, including:

See all service areas

Related Services

If rekeying doesn't meet your needs, explore our other locksmith services:

Residential Locksmith — House lockouts, deadbolt installation, and more
Lock Replacement — Full lock replacement for damaged or upgraded hardware
Smart Lock Installation — Electronic and keypad locks for modern homes
House Lockout — Fast emergency entry when locked out

Helpful Guides

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between rekeying and replacing a lock?

Rekeying changes the lock's internal pins so old keys no longer work — you keep your existing hardware. Replacing swaps the whole lock. Rekeying is usually faster and lower-cost; we advise which fits.

When should I rekey?

After moving into a home, losing a key, a tenant change, or a break-in — any time you are unsure who has a key.

Can you key all my locks to one key?

Often yes — we can rekey multiple locks to match a single key where the hardware allows. Tell us how many locks for a quote.

Do you come to me?

Yes — we rekey on-site across the Sarasota area, with a clear quote before work.

Need a Lock Rekeying Service?

Call +1 (941) 297-5289 — available 7 AM to 10 PM daily, with after-hours on-call service.

Call (941) 297-5289 Book

Rekeying by City

We provide rekeying across our Southwest Florida service areas:

Sarasota · Bradenton · Venice · North Port · Lakewood Ranch · Siesta Key · Longboat Key · Palmer Ranch · Nokomis · Osprey · Gulf Gate · Bee Ridge · Palmetto · Port Charlotte · Englewood · Rotonda West.

Lock Rekeying — Keep Your Locks, Get New Keys